Legitimate Authority

Coats of arms of prince electors surround the
imperial coat of arms; Holy Roman Empire

Legitimate Authority |
Friday – November 20, 2026

During these testing times we are often asked to think about authority and whether or not authority is legitimate, and yes this is a fair question: what grants authority legitimacy, and really what grants temporal power legitimacy, read "Temporal Power"? If we look at the world of the Holy Roman Empire (Sacrum Imperium Romanum) before around 1307, it becomes clear that the Holy Roman Emperor was granted power through two distinct institutions: that of the Church, the Roman Catholic Church, and the peerage, and in turn the peerage controlled the land.
    Verily, do not let yourself live in the delusion that the Holy Roman Emperor held absolute power over the land, but also do not allow the modern notion of a symbolic ruler to fool you either. In the Holy Roman Empire, the Emperor was truly appointed by the Creator, and only the priesthood, the bridge between the heaven and the earth, had any true authority, and yes there was surely politics and schism between the Emperor and the peerage and within the ranks of the peerage, but this politics had no consequence on the course of the Empire, because power was never concentrated into the hands of one man, of one man with merely temporal inclinations, and besides the Holy Roman Emperor had been granted some initiation into the priesthood, while he was never a part of the priesthood either. Of course, similar arrangements can be found throughout history and the most notable example is perhaps ancient China and ancient Egypt, but really what I am referring to here is the mandate of heaven. If today power has no authority, or at least if the authority of power today is based upon merely profane and egalitarian notions of nationhood, democracy, and the humanist axiom, power in the Holy Roman Empire and in the old world was derived from the authority of the clergy, and the clergy surely had authority, an authentic and spiritual authority.
    Let us also understand that the word "authority" and the word "power" are not exactly synonymous, at least not in this contect, for what we may think of as authority is much more akin to knowledge or wisdom, really something that is earned, while power is much more closely related to the profane, the earthly, the material, and this is why I have made the distinction between spiritual authority and temporal power clear in the past, and many scholars would also point out this distinction as well. Now, power without proper authority, proper justification, is really something that is truly temporal, something that relates to the world without contemplation, really something that relates to the world through action, the wielding of the sword. Of course, both authority and power are needed in the world, but power without authority is nothing but dense and violent ignorance, really something akin to a blind warrior wielding the sword; the warrior must see the world for what it is, and this is the purpose of the clergy. See, if the clergy is placed at the center of the wheel, then one can think of authority as the whole circumference of the wheel; yes, without both you would have no wheel, but without the center of the wheel, there could be no direction.* Yes, the wheel must derive its path and its power from the authority of the center, the inner core of wisdom, and this is why authority and power are never equivalent: if we think of authority as something esoteric and hidden from the purview of the unqualified, read "Qualification", we may think of power as something revealed and exoteric and maybe even ornamental, something that most people can related to, which is the form of the Church and what moderns call religion and faith, but again form requires substance and substance requires essence. I believe a useful thing to think about in relation to authority and power is that of faith and knowledge: just as power is perfectly unjustified without authority, religion may at any rate seem quite unjustified without knowledge. Yes, things in our world require propper and qualified justification, and the simplest person should know this, and in fact I would argue that the simplest person does know this.
    Now, today on the other hand, we live in a world where there is no true and proper justification for power, which is why power, politics, influence, capital, and the rest seem to always change their reason for being (raison d'être), and to this same extent, this is also the reason why people feel somewhat ashamed of power or on behalf of power, that is when power is exposed, when the emperor is naked, because this painful and obvious fact becomes too stark to ignore, and so we must move on to another justification. Is politics really just this, is it just about finding a new material reason for power, for the circumference of the wheel? You see, people are very inventive without the intervention of the holy and the sacred, but most people lack the ability to receive divine instruction and since most people also are not knowledgeable enough, the world must be reduced to a veritable chaos in order to justify the the concentration of power into the hands of fewer and fewer people, but also people who are themselves unqualified to hold power. I suppose too that the new justification is something material and supposedly "objective" based on reason, but this reason always keeps changing and you can always invent a new justification for this or that power, read "My Views on the State as a Function of the Decay of Modernity". Power is simply not a good thing, at least not on its own, and this is why we recognize that power must be conserved rather than simply exercised on the world, as if power was a muscle that had to be trained. Too many calamities and too many strange actions occur due to unjustifiable power; some men are simply not qualified to hold any power, and even if a man is qualified to hold power, he will do no good with that power unless he is guided by divine law. Again, without vision and without thought most men are fools, and this is no less true for men holding power, and note, again, that most men who hold power today, in this our 21st century, are nothing but completely unqualified, completely blind to reality, and completely corrupted on all levels. Again, substance is rather vapid without essence, but more than vapid, substance is helpless without essence, read "The Primordial Body".

Reginald Drax (AKA, M. C. Dutt) – November 20, 2026.

Footnote(s)
* Understand that I am borrowing the wheel from Hindu mythology—the Dharmachakra (धर्मचक्र)—as quite a proper and useful analogy here, even though I am mainly writing about Western society in this context, read "Modern Civilization". For more on this point and on the history of authority and power, I direct you to René Guénon's work: Spiritual Authority & Temporal Power, 1929.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

June 14, 2025

May 22, 2025

May 30, 2025